Manila Principles

1. Shield
   Intermediaries should be shielded by law from liability for third party content
   1. Copyright
      Yes, except ....
   2. Defamation
      
      1. {Yes.sec}
      2. {Maybe.sec}
      3. {No.sec}
   3. Dangerous
      
      1. {Yes.sec}
      2. {Maybe.sec}
      3. {No.sec}
   4. Privacy
      
      1. {Yes.sec}
      2. {Maybe.sec}
      3. {No.sec}
   5. Consumer Protection
      
      1. {Yes.sec}
      2. {Maybe.sec}
      3. {No.sec}
2. Court Order
   Content must not be required to be restricted without an order by a judicial authority
   1. Copyright
      
      1. {Yes.sec}
      2. {Maybe.sec}
      3. {No.sec}
   2. Defamation
      
      1. {Yes.sec}
      2. {Maybe.sec}
      3. {No.sec}
   3. Dangerous
      
      1. {Yes.sec}
      2. {Maybe.sec}
      3. {No.sec}
   4. Privacy
      
      1. {Yes.sec}
      2. {Maybe.sec}
      3. {No.sec}
   5. Consumer Protection
      
      1. {Yes.sec}
      2. {Maybe.sec}
      3. {No.sec}
3. Notice
   Requests for restrictions of content must be clear, be unambiguous, and follow due process
   1. Copyright
      
      1. {Yes.sec}
      2. {Maybe.sec}
      3. {No.sec}
   2. Defamation
      
      1. {Yes.sec}
      2. {Maybe.sec}
      3. {No.sec}
   3. Dangerous
      
      1. {Yes.sec}
      2. {Maybe.sec}
      3. {No.sec}
   4. Privacy
      
      1. {Yes.sec}
      2. {Maybe.sec}
      3. {No.sec}
   5. Consumer Protection
      
      1. {Yes.sec}
      2. {Maybe.sec}
      3. {No.sec}
4. Proportionality
   Laws and content restriction orders and practices must comply with the tests of necessity and proportionality
   1. Copyright
      
      1. {Yes.sec}
      2. {Maybe.sec}
      3. {No.sec}
   2. Defamation
      
      1. {Yes.sec}
      2. {Maybe.sec}
      3. {No.sec}
   3. Dangerous
      
      1. {Yes.sec}
      2. {Maybe.sec}
      3. {No.sec}
   4. Privacy
      
      1. {Yes.sec}
      2. {Maybe.sec}
      3. {No.sec}
   5. Consumer Protection
      
      1. {Yes.sec}
      2. {Maybe.sec}
      3. {No.sec}
5. Due Process
   Laws and content restriction policies and practices must respect due process
   1. Copyright
      
      1. {Yes.sec}
      2. {Maybe.sec}
      3. {No.sec}
   2. Defamation
      
      1. {Yes.sec}
      2. {Maybe.sec}
      3. {No.sec}
   3. Dangerous
      
      1. {Yes.sec}
      2. {Maybe.sec}
      3. {No.sec}
   4. Privacy
      
      1. {Yes.sec}
      2. {Maybe.sec}
      3. {No.sec}
   5. Consumer Protection
      
      1. {Yes.sec}
      2. {Maybe.sec}
      3. {No.sec}
6. Transparency
   Transparency and accountability must be built into laws and content restriction policies and practices
   1. Copyright
      
      1. {Yes.sec}
      2. {Maybe.sec}
      3. {No.sec}
   2. Defamation
      
      1. {Yes.sec}
      2. {Maybe.sec}
      3. {No.sec}
   3. Dangerous
      
      1. {Yes.sec}
      2. {Maybe.sec}
      3. {No.sec}
   4. Privacy
      
      1. {Yes.sec}
      2. {Maybe.sec}
      3. {No.sec}
   5. Consumer Protection
      
      1. {Yes.sec}
      2. {Maybe.sec}
      3. {No.sec}